from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
Culture

From Florence to Timothée, is being scrutinized the price of fame?

© Getty

On November 19th, 2026, actress Florence Pugh posted on Instagram in response to recent rumours and critiques from people online about her body, saying plainly: “I’m disturbed.” Florence’s post was in reaction to discussion online about an apparent change to her appearance, sparked by her attendance at the Governors Awards 2026 this week, which people have been alleging is due to Ozempic and/or cosmetic surgeries.

from florence to timothe is being scrutinized the price of fame 1
1/81/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
2/82/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
3/83/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
4/84/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
5/85/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
6/86/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
7/87/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram
from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
8/88/8 via @florencepugh on Instagram

Florence responded to these claims with the apt phrase, “What the f*cking h*ll guys,” and by shutting down the rumours with the truth: she’s simply been treating her body better than she was before. “I turned 30 and my New Year’s resolution was to change my relationship with alcohol, and to be able to do at least one pull up in the gym,” she explained. “Guess how much weight I’ve lost in all of that? 2 pounds.”

Not only does Florence explain why her appearance may be different than it was a few years ago in her post, but she asks the question: why is this constant scrutiny so normalised when it comes to celebrities? As Florence said, “I’m aware that the culture on socials currently is very interested in talking about people’s surgery and Ozmepic changes. … [But] I think it’s important to remember, that you’re still picking my body apart.”

from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
© Vanity Fair

Similarly, Florence’s Dune co-star Timothée Chalamet’s cover interview with Vanity Fair this week has people speculating that he’s also become more reserved in reaction to online criticism, sharing less publicly. Thanks to being one of the most discussed actors globally, and his relationship with one of the most talked about women on the internet, Kylie Jenner, Timothée has been at the hands of a growing amount of criticism this year.

“There were moments,” [Timothée] told Vanity Fair, when he realized about his relationship with the public: “Oh, something has shifted.” One of these moments may have been earlier this year when people turned on Timothée for his comments about ballet and opera being outdated art forms. While his comment was arguably true at best and misguided at worst, people reacted in extreme ways, calling for his cancellation.

Is it simply the role of the celebrity to endure constant invasive and sometimes aggressive scrutiny from the public? Is it part of the job description, and what justifies them being awarded so much success and paid such huge amounts? The reward surely outweighs the costs, given that most actors of Florence Pugh or Timothée Chalamet’s scale are set up for life. They could retire tomorrow, something most people of the same age could only dream of.

However, I'm not sure that the price of any job - even the best job in the world - should be this much unregulated criticism, especially when a small amount of scrutiny on the internet left unchecked can often snowball into extreme levels of hate and verbal aggression. We don't often even give this much scrutiny to our politicians, individuals whose job is fundamentally to serve the people. So why should actors and musicians expect it?

from-florence-to-timothe-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame
© Getty

Part of the reason we're overly critical of people in the public eye is because there's an unspoken connection between being a celebrity and a role mode. Many have argued that signing up for fame means that you're also signing up to adhere to a higher standard in the way you look and behave, because part of the job involves being someone we can aspire to. This is a particularly common argument when it comes to celebrities with younger audiences, like Taylor Swift or Ariana Grande, who are expected to behave as role models to teen/kid fans.

This argument has also been prevalent this year in the vicious debate online surrounding Ariana Grande's body, with people commenting on her apparent weight loss asking whether, as someone in the public eye, she's promoting an unhealthy body standard.

The attitude surrounding this controversy is complicated because it argues that even by existing in the public eye in a way that appears unhealthy, Ariana Grande is harmfully impacting her young fans. So what's the solution? She should change her appearance or go into hiding?

from-florence-to-timothee-is-being-scrutinized-the-price-of-fame

Online warriors defense that they're simply "protecting the children" with their criticism of women's bodies falls apart when the likes of Chris Brown, Johnny Depp, and more are allowed to maintain their celebrity status despite immoral and illegal behaviours. Society allowing people whose behavior is fundamentally not aspirational to maintain a platform means you have to ask whether female celebrities' simply changing their appearance should ignite such a backlash.

The conclusion to all of this isn't a simple one, given that celebrities putting themselves in the public eye will always result in people forming opinions on them, sometimes complimentary and sometimes critical. What we can do is hold back from sharing our unwarranted opinions online, especially when it comes to people's bodies and appearances, as it's rarely helpful. If you still need to harass someone for their choices on the internet, the Donald Trump can still be contacted via Truth Social.


Profile photo of Robyn Pullen

Written by

Robyn Pullen

Owning tabis will change me

Stickers